| Date | Album / Release | Publication | Author |
|---|---|---|---|
| 7 March 1970 | Stormbringer! | Melody Maker | Jeremy Gilbert |
| 16 May 1970 | Stormbringer! | Cash Box | Anonymous |
| 3 April 1971 | The Road To Ruin | Record World | Anonymous |
| 4 December 1971 | Bless The Weather | Melody Maker | Andrew Means |
| 9 December 1971 | Bless The Weather | Rolling Stone | Stephen Holden |
| 25 December 1971 | Bless The Weather | Record Mirror | BM |
| 1 March 1973 | Inside Out | Supersnazz | Anonymous |
| 7 April 1973 | Solid Air | Sounds | Anonymous |
| 29 September 1973 | Inside Out | New Musical Express | Ian MacDonald |
| 1 October 1973 | Inside Out | Sounds | Jeremy Gilbert |
| 25 January 1975 | Sunday’s Child | New Musical Express | Neil Spencer |
| 1 March 1975 | Sunday’s Child | Zig Zag | Andy Childs |
| 12 March 1977 | So Far So Good | Record Mirror | Sheila Prophet |
| 26 March 1977 | So Far So Good | New Musical Express | Monty Smith |
| 9 April 1977 | So Far So Good | Melody Maker | Geoff Brown |
| 1 November 1977 | So Far So Good | Stereo Review | Noel Coppage |
| 19 November 1977 | One World | New Musical Express | Monty Smith |
| 26 November 1977 | One World | Sounds | Vivien Goldsmith |
| 10 December 1977 | One World | Melody Maker | Mark Prendergast |
| 24 January 1978 | Martyn’s One World | Gongster | Dave Belbin |
| 25 October 1980 | Grace And Danger | New Musical Express | Angus MacKinnon |
| 1 November 1980 | Grace And Danger | Melody Maker | John Orme |
| 15 November 1980 | Grace And Danger | Sounds | David Lewis |
| 28 May 1981 | Grace And Danger | Rolling Stone | Don Shewey |
| 19 September 1981 | Glorious Fool | Melody Maker | Steve Sutherland |
| 3 October 1981 | Glorious Fool | Record Mirror | Mark Cooper |
| 10 October 1981 | Glorious Fool | New Musical Express | Graham Lock |
| 18 September 1982 | Well Kept Secret | Sounds | David Lewis |
| 4 September 1982 | Well Kept Secret | Melody Maker | Paul Colbert |
| 4 September 1982 | Well Kept Secret | New Musical Express | Danny Baker |
| 3 December 1983 | Philentropy | New Musical Express | Ian Penman |
| 10 November 1984 | Sapphire | New Musical Express | Richard Cook |
| 1 March 1986 | Classic John Martyn | New Musical Express | Andy Gill |
| 8 March 1986 | Piece By Piece | Sounds | Glyn Brown |
| 8 March 1986 | Piece By Piece | New Musical Express | Len Brown |
| 31 May 1986 | Live From London (Video) | Sounds | Hugh Fielder |
| 1 July 1987 | Live At Leeds | Q Magazine | Andy Kershaw |
| 1 August 1987 | Live At Leeds | Folk Roots | Nick Beale |
| 1 March 1988 | The Electric John Martyn (Original CD Release) | Q Magazine | David Hepworth |
| 18 March 1988 | Foundations | New York Times | Stephen Holden |
| 1 March 1990 | The Apprentice | Q Magazine | Anonymous |
| 1 March 1990 | The Apprentice | Q Magazine | Peter Kane |
| 1 August 1990 | The Apprentice Tour (Video) | Unknown | Monty Smith |
| 1 August 1990 | The Apprentice Tour (Video) | Unknown | Mark Prendergast |
| 8 September 1990 | The Apprentice Tour (Video) | New Musical Expres | Stuart Marconie |
| 1 September 1991 | Cooltide | Q Magazine | Philip Thomas |
| 1 October 1991 | Cooltide | Vox | Andy Robson |
| 21 March 1992 | BBC Radio 1 Live In Concert | New Musical Express | David Quantick |
| 18 April 1992 | BBC Radio 1 Live In Concert | New Musical Express | Anonymous |
| 18 April 1992 | Live At Leeds | New Musical Express | Anonymous |
| 1 May 1992 | BBC Radio 1 Live In Concert | Q Magazine | Peter Kane |
| 15 May 1992 | Sunday’s Child | Melody Maker | Chris Roberts |
| 15 May 1992 | Sapphire | Melody Maker | Chris Roberts |
| 15 May 1992 | The Road To Ruin | Melody Maker | Chris Roberts |
| 1 June 1992 | BBC Radio 1 Live In Concert | Vox | Andy Robson |
| 1 January 1993 | Solid Air / One World | Mojo | Mark Cooper |
| 1 September 1993 | No Little Boy | Vox | Andy Robson |
| 20 July 1996 | And | Music Week | Anonymous |
| 25 July 1996 | And | The Sunday Times | Andrew Smith |
| 26 July 1996 | And | Daily Mail | Spencer Bright |
| 27 July 1996 | And | The Telegraph | James Bennett |
| 28 July 1996 | And | The Observer | Neil Spencer |
| 1 August 1996 | And | Mojo | Mark Cooper |
| 2 August 1996 | And | The Times | David Sinclair |
| 2 August 1996 | And | The Guardian | Andrew Smith |
| 2 August 1996 | And | The Independent | Andy Gill |
| 3 August 1996 | And | The Herald | Rob Adams |
| 1 September 1996 | And | Q Magazine | Phil Sutcliffe |
| 1 September 1996 | And | Top | Anonymous |
| 1 September 1996 | And | Vox | Tommy Tide |
| 18 March 1998 | The Church With One Bell | The Scotsman | Alan Taylor |
| 21 March 1998 | The Church With One Bell | Metro | Dominic Pedler |
| 21 March 1998 | The Church With One Bell | The Daily Telegraph | Raphael Lyne |
| 1 June 2000 | Classics | Classic Rock | Andy Robson |
| 1 July 2000 | Glasgow Walker | Mojo | Chris Ingham |
| 1 July 2000 | Classics | Mojo | Chris Ingham |
| 1 October 2000 | Solid Air | Q Magazine | Rob Beattie |
| 1 February 2003 | Solid Air: Classics Revisited | Uncut | Anonymous |
| 23 April 2004 | On The Cobbles | The Scotsman | Fiona Shepherd |
| 1 May 2004 | On The Cobbles | BBC Website | Peter Marsh |
| 15 May 2004 | On The Cobbles | The Times | Nigel Williamson |
| 1 June 2004 | On The Cobbles | Mojo | James McNair |
| 26 June 2004 | One World (Deluxe Edition) | Radio Times | Phill Jupitus |
| 28 June 2004 | On The Cobbles | Belfast Telegraph | Anonymous |
| 11 August 2004 | Late Night John | Uncut | Anonymous |
| 1 October 2004 | Mad Dog Days | Uncut | Anonymous |
| 1 November 2005 | Stormbringer! (Remastered And Expanded) | The Word | Simon Waldman |
| 1 November 2005 | The Road To Ruin (Remastered And Expanded) | The Word | Simon Waldman |
| 4 November 2005 | Bless The Weather (Remastered And Expanded) | The Guradian | Dorian Lynskey |
| 1 January 2006 | London Conversation (Remastered And Expanded) | Record Collector | Euan Andrews |
| 1 January 2006 | The Tumbler (Remastered And Expanded) | Record Collector | Euan Andrews |
| 1 January 2006 | Bless The Weather (Remastered And Expanded) | Record Collector | Euan Andrews |
| 1 January 2006 | Inside Out (Remastered And Expanded) | Record Collector | Euan Andrews |
| 1 January 2006 | Sunday’s Child (Remastered And Expanded) | Record Collector | Euan Andrews |
| 1 September 2006 | On Air | Uncut | Mick Houghton |
| 7 September 2006 | Solid Air (Remastered) | The Daily Telegraph | Robert Sandall |
| 1 October 2006 | The Apprentice In Concert (DVD) | Record Collector | Ali MacQueen |
| 1 October 2006 | The Apprentice (DVD) | Mojo | Fred Dellar |
| 1 May 2007 | Solid Air | Uncut | David Stubbs |
| 20 February 2008 | The Battle Of Medway | Uncut | Paul Moody |
| 1 April 2008 | The Man Upstairs (DVD) | Record Collector | Graham Bent |
| 1 April 2008 | The Man Upstairs (DVD) | Guitarist Magazine | Anonymous |
| 1 September 2008 | Ain’t No Saint | Uncut | Rob Young |
| 7 September 2008 | Ain’t No Saint | The Independent | Nick Coleman |
| 1 November 2008 | Ain’t No Saint | Mojo | Phil Sutcliffe |
| 1 November 2008 | Ain’t No Saint | Record Collector | Terry Staunton |
| 1 March 2009 | May You Never, The Very Best Of John Martyn | Guitar Techniques | Anonymous |
| 11 May 2009 | Ain't No Saint | Rolling Stone | David Fricke |
| 22 May 2009 | Solid Air (Deluxe Edition) | Uncut | Alistair McKay |
| 1 October 2010 | Live At Leeds (Deluxe Edition) | Uncut | David Cavanagh |
| 1 November 2010 | Live At Leeds (Deluxe Edition) | Q Magazine | Peter Kane |
| 1 November 2010 | Live At Leeds (Deluxe Edition) | Record Collector | Marco Rossi |
| 1 November 2010 | Live At Leeds (Deluxe Edition) | Mojo | Jim Irwin |
| 1 May 2011 | Heaven And Earth | Good Times | Anonymous |
| 1 May 2011 | Johnny Boy Would Love This | Good Times | Anonymous |
| 5 May 2011 | Heaven And Earth | The Daily Telegraph | Martin Chilton |
| 11 May 2011 | Heaven And Earth | The Herald | Ketih Bruce |
| 13 May 2011 | Heaven And Earth | The Independent | Andy Gill |
| 15 May 2011 | Heaven And Earth | The Independent | Nick Coleman |
| 15 May 2011 | Heaven And Earth | The Sunday Times | Anonymous |
| 15 May 2011 | Heaven And Earth | The Mail On Sunday | Anonymous |
| 17 May 2011 | Heaven And Earth | The Scotsman | Fiona Shepherd |
| 1 June 2011 | Heaven And Earth | Record Collector | Marco Rossi |
| 1 June 2011 | Heaven And Earth | Mojo | James McNair |
| 1 June 2011 | Heaven And Earth | Uncut | Graeme Thomson |
| 1 June 2011 | Heaven And Earth | The Word | David Hepworth |
| 1 July 2011 | Heaven And Earth | Q Magazine | Ian Harrison |
| 5 July 2011 | Johnny Boy Would Love This | RTE Ten Website | Paddy Kehoe |
| 12 August 2011 | Johnny Boy Would Love This | BBC Website | Sid Smith |
| 16 August 2011 | Johnny Boy Would Love This | New York Times | Jon Pareles |
| 22 August 2011 | Johnny Boy Would Love This | The Daily Telegraph | Martin Chilton |
| 1 April 2012 | One World… One John (DVD) | Word Magazine | Laura Barton |
| 1 August 2012 | One World… One John (DVD) | RTE Ten Website | Paddy Kehoe |
| 27 September 2013 | The Island Years | Daily Mirror | Anonymous |
| 1 November 2013 | The Island Years | Q Magazine | John Aizlewood |
| 1 November 2013 | The Island Years | Mojo | Mat Snow |
| 1 November 2013 | The Island Years | Shindig | Mike Fornatale |
| 1 November 2013 | The Island Years | Classic Rock | David Stubbs |
| 29 July 2014 | London Conversation (Vinyl) | Mojo | Jim Irvin |
| 1 November 2014 | The Best Of The Island Years | Shindig | Tom Patterson |
| 1 December 2014 | The Best Of The Island Years | Record Collector | Oregano Rathbone |
| 1 May 2017 | Head and Heart: The Acoustic John Martyn | Record Collector | Nick Dalton |
| 17 May 2017 | Head and Heart: The Acoustic John Martyn | RTE Website | Paddy Kehoe |
| 4 November 2018 | Stormbringer! And The Road To Ruin | The Arts Desk | Kieron Tyler |
| 1 February 2023 | The Apprentice | Mojo | John Aizlewood |
| 1 February 2023 | The Apprentice | Prog Magazine | James McNair |
Highlights
